A Bibliometric Literature Review Analysis of Public Sentiment Towards the Implementation of ETLE Cameras at Intersection Four

Agung Nur Hidayat; Fahmi Nabhan Luthfiansyah; Sevan Alif Maulana; Erni Sari Lumban Toruan; Mohamad Taufik

doi:10.31004/riggs.v4i2.1463

Authors

Agung Nur Hidayat University of Majalengka
Fahmi Nabhan Luthfiansyah Universitas Majalengka
Sevan Alif Maulana University of Majalengka
Erni Sari Lumban Toruan University of Majalengka
Mohamad Taufik Ministry of Public Work, Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31004/riggs.v4i2.1463

Keywords:

Road, Transportation, Traffic Highway, Camera ETLE

Abstract

The implementation of the Electronic Traffic Law Enforcement (ETLE) system at the Kadipaten intersection in Majalengka is a strategic step to improve traffic order through electronic camera-based surveillance. This study aims to evaluate public sentiment toward ETLE technology using a bibliometric approach and keyword visualization analysis. The Bibliometric method was used to collect and analyze 1,000 publications from Google Scholar, with the assistance of the Publish or Perish and VOSviewer software. The results indicate that the majority of studies highlight the important role of cameras in improving traffic efficiency and road safety. Keywords such as video camera, traffic camera, speed camera, and radar frequently appear, reflecting the high level of attention given to sensor technology and traffic monitoring. Keyword network visualization also reveals a strong connection between driver behavior, road design, and the effectiveness of ETLE cameras. This study provides recommendations to improve public acceptance through education, outreach, and the development of inclusive and transparent policies.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

X. Deng, L. Wang, J. Gui, P. Jiang, X. Cheng, F. Zeng and S. Wan, "A review of 6G autonomous intelligent transportation systems: Mechanisms, applications and challenges," Journal of System Architecture,142, p. 102929, 2023.

A. Megarestya, A. I. Rifai and M. Isradi, "The Horizontal Curved Geometric Design with Autocad® Civil 3D on Jalan Muara Wahau, East Kalimantan," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 237-250, 2023.

L. R. Rosaria, A. I. Rifai and J. Prasetijo, "THE GEOMETRIC DESIGN OF HORIZONTAL ALIGNMENT: A CASEOFPOST-HARVEST INFRASTRUCTURE CORN DRYING CENTER, TUBAN, EAST JAV," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 224-236, 2022.

A. I. Rifai, H. Thalib, D. Prayogo and M. Isradi, "Customer Satisfaction and Road Perfomance in Long Segment Maintenence Contract: Application of an Urban Road Network," UIJRT United International Journal of Research & Technology, 3(09), pp. 10-19, 2022.

I. Pangesti, A. I. Rifai and J. Prasetijo, "The Horizontal Curved Geometric Planning Using the Autocad® Civil 3D Method on Tanah Merah Road, Banjarbaru City, South Kalimantan," Indonesian Jounal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 265-287, 2022.

R. B. Nugroho, A. I. Rifai and A. F. Akhir, "The Geometric Design of Horizontal Alignment: A Case of Bojonggede-Kemang Area Route, West Java Indonesia," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 331-343, 2022.

A. I. Rifai, M. G. D. Putra, M. Isradi, A. Mufhidin and J. Prasetijo, "Evaluation of Selection of Public Transport Mode Corridor Blok M–Bundaran Hotel Indonesian in the New Normal Era with Stated Preference," IJEBD International Journal of Entrepreneurship And Business Preference eISSN 2597-4785 pISSN 2597-4750, 5(4), pp. 729-805, 2022.

D. A. Sahara, A. I. Rifai and M. A. Irianto, "Vertical Alignment Design of Special Operational Road: A Case TPA Bangkonol, Banten," Citizen: Jurnal Ilmiah Multidisiplin Indonesia, 2, pp. 924-933, 2022.

A. I. Rifai and J. Prasetijo, "Performance Analysis of Sentul Circuit Roundabout and Alternatif Road Sentul Bogor.," IJTI (International Journal Of Transportation And Infarstructure), 2022.

Y. Immanuel, A. I. Rifai and J. Prasetijo, "THE ROAD PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF THE TUAH MADANI ROUNDABOUT, BATAM-INDONESIA," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 27-36, 2022.

M. R. Farid, A. I. Rifai and M. Taufik, "The Alignment Horizontal Design of Alternative Road: A Case of Jalan Subang – Cikamurang, West Java," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 344-356, 2022.

M. A. Wahyudi, A. I. Rifai and J. Prasetijo, "Analysis of the Effectiveness of Traffic Flow Diversion on Road Performance: A Case of Jalan Gajah Mada Development Project, Batam.," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), 92-102., pp. 92-102., 2022.

E. O. Joice, A. I. Rifai and M. Taufik, "The Link Road Design of Jalan Plupuh Tanon And Jalan Gabugan Section 1, Sragen Indonesia," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 211-223, 2022.

S. Salsabila, A. I. Rifai and M. Taufik, "THE GEOMETRIC DESIGN OF HORIZONTAL CURVES USING THE AUTOCAD CIVIL 3D® METHOD: A CASE STUDY OF TRANS FLORES ROADS," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 251-264, 2022.

H. Dwiatmoko, M. Isradi, J. Prasetijo, M. M. Rohani, S. R. Abdila and A. I. Rifai, "Accident Prevention and Traffic Safety for Sekolah Alam Bekasi-(KidSafe)," Accident Prevention and Traffic Safety for Sekolah Alam Bekasi-(KidSafe), 2(1), pp. 56-63, 2023.

S. H. Maulana, A. I. Rifai and M. Isradi, "The Horizontal Curved Geometric Redesign on Jalan Kayu Api Kuala Penaso, Riau Using the Autocad Civil 3d® Method," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 318-330, 2022.

A. I. Rifai, S. P. Hadiwardoyo, A. G. Correira, P. A. Pereira and P. Cortez, "THE DATA MINING APPLIED FOR THE PREDICTION OF HIGHWAY," International Journal of Technology, pp. 751-761, 2015.

A. I. Rifai, Y. A. Sugiarti, M. Isradi and A. Mufhidin, "Analysis of Road Performance and the impact of Development in Pasar Minggu, Jakarta (Case Study of," International Journal of Civil Engineering, 6(1), pp. 68-74, 2021.

M. Isradi, N. D. Nareswari, A. I. Rifai and J. Prasetijo, "Performance Analysis of Road Section and Unsignalized Intersections in Order to Prevent Traffic Jams on Jl H. Djole–Jl. Pasar Lama," International Journal of Civil Engineering, 6(1), pp. 56-67, 2021.

A. I. Rifai, T. Wibowo, M. Isradi and A. Mufhidin, "On-Street Parking and Its Impact on Road Performance: Case Comersil Area in Jakarta City," World Journal of Civil Engineering, 1 (1), pp. 10-18, 2020.

A. I. Rifai, Y. A. Surgiarti, M. Isradi and A. Mufhidin, "Analysis of Road Performance and the impact of Development in Pasar Minggu, Jakarta (Case Study of," International Journal of Civil Engineering, 6 (1), pp. 68-74, 2021.

M. F. Assalam, A. I. Rifai and M. Taufik, "THE EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS OF FRONTAGE ROAD ON JALAN MARGONDA RAYA, DEPOK," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, pp. 383-396, 2022.

Y. Rachmadina, A. I. Rifai and S. Handayani, "Traffic Management Effectivity of Bulak Kapal Underpass Development, Bekasi Indonesia," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 369-382, 2022.

M. Isradi, H. Dwiatmoko, J. Prasetijo, A. I. Rifai, Z. F. Zainal, G. Zhang and H. Y. Firdaus, "Identification of hazardous road sites: a comparison of blackspot methodology of Narogong Road Bekasi and Johor Federal Roads," Sinergi Indonesia, 28(2), pp. 347-354, 2024.

A. Oktobrianto, A. I. Rifai and A. F. Akhir, "THE TRAFFIC CHARACTERISTIC ANALYSIS OF JALAN CIATER RAYA SOUTH TANGERANG, INDONESIA," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 437-450, 2022.

A. Andriyani, W. B. Dermawan, M. Isradi and A. I. Rifai, "Operational Performance Analysis of Rapid Transit Bus (BRT) Corridor 11 in Pulogebang Bus Station," World Journal of Civil Engineering, 2(2), pp. 71-80, 2021.

J. P. Bharadiya, "Artificial Intelligence in Transportation Systems A Critical Review," American Journal of Computing and Engineering, 6(1), pp. 35-45, 2023.

J. N. Njoku, C. I. Nwakanma, G. C. Amaizu and D.-S. Kim, "Prospects and challenges of Metaverse application in data-driven intelligent transportation systems," IET Intelligent Transport Systems, 17(1), pp. 1-21, 2022.

N. Ulchurriyyah, A. I. Rifai and M. Taufik, "THE GEOMETRIC REDESIGN OF HORIZONTAL CURVED USING AutoCAD CIVIL 3D®: A CASE JALAN GARUDA –JALAN MOH. HATTA, TASIKMALAYA WEST JAVA," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 288-303, 2022.

M. Syaifullah, Y. Kadir and F. L. Desei, "Kinerja Simpang Empat Tak Bersinyal Menggunakan Metode PKJI 2023 dan Software VISSIM," Konstruksia, 15(2), pp. 147-163, 2024.

L. P. Joseph, A. I. Rifai and M. Taufik, "THE UNSIGNALED INTERSECTION PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS OF ARTERIAL ACCESS ROAD AT KARAWANG BARAT 1TOLL GATE, WEST JAVA," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, 1(1), pp. 451-459, 2022.

H. A. Setiaputri, M. Isradi, A. I. Rifai, A. Mufhidin and J. Presetijo, "Analysis Of Urban Road Damage With Pavement Condition Index (PCI) And Surface Distress Index (SDI) Methods," ADRI International Journal of Science, Engineering and Technology, 6(1), pp. 10-19, 2021.

W. Wincent, A. I. Rifai and M. Isradi, "The Road Performance Analysis in Jalan Ahmad Yani Batam Using IHCM 1997," Indonesian Journal of Multidisciplinary Science, pp. 103-116, 2022.

I. Bisio, C. Garibotto, H. Haleem, F. Lavagetto and A. Sciarrone, "A Systematic Review of Drone Based Road Traffic Monitoring System," Ieee Access, 10, pp. 101537-101555, 2020.

A. Kumalawati, T. M. W. Sir and D. Woda, "Kinerja Simpang Bersinyal Pada Simpang Empat di Kota Ende," Jurnal Teknik Sipil, Vol. 11, No. 1, pp. 41-48, 2022.

A. I. Rifai and E. S. Aulia, "Analysis of Factors Causing Traffic Accidents on Sultan Agung Bekasi," Neutron 18(2), pp. 1-9, 2019.

A. Tiessa, S. Lesmana and R. Indayatun, "Analisis Efektivitas Penerapan Electronic Traffic Law Enforcement (ETLE) Dalam Sistem Penegakan Hukum di Kabupaten Tanggerang," SOCIED, 8(1), pp. 5-14, 2025.

L. Magriasti, "Efektivitas Tilang Elektronik (ETLE) dalam Penegakan Hukum Kota Padang," Jurnal ISO: Jurnal Ilmu Sosial, Politik dan Humaniora. 5(1), pp. 14-14, 2025.

D. F. A. Pratama and P. Gultom, "Pelaksanaan Electronic Traffic Law Enforcement (ETLE) Polda Metro Jaya," LEX LAGUENS: Jurnal Kajian Hukum dan Keadilan, 3(1), pp. 72-85, 2025.

D. McCarty and H. W. Kim, "Risky behaviors and road safety: An exploration of age and gender influences on road accident rates," PLoS one, 19(1), p. e0296663, 2024.

M. H. Fikri, M. M. Ulum and N. L. D. M. Sari, "Literature review Implementasi kecerdasan buatan untuk Prediksi dan Pengelolaan Kemacetan Lalu Lintas di Perkotaan," Prosiding Seminar Nasional Informatika. Vol. 2., pp. 449-456, 2024.

W. Narendroputro and E. Z. Rusfian, "The Innovation Capacity of the Electronic Traffic Law Enforcement (ETLE) of the Indonesian National Police Viewed vy the Observatory of Public Sector Innovation (OPSI) Framework," Jurnal Public Policy, 9(4), pp. 262-269, 2023.

D. N. Al Husaeni, A. B. D. Nandiyanto and R. Maryanti, "Bibliometric analysis of special needs education keyword using VOSviewer indexed by google scholar," Indonesian Jurnal of Community and Special Needs Education, 3(1), pp. 1-10, 2023.

A. Montazeri, S. Mohammadi, P. M. Hesari, M. Ghaemi, H. Riazi and Z. Sheikhi-Mobarakeh, "Preliminary guideline for reporting bibliometric reviews of the biomedical literature (BIBLIO): a minimum requirements," Systematic Reviews,12(1), p. 239, 2023.

N. Donthu, S. Kumar, D. Mukherjee, N. Pandey and W. M. Lim, "How to conduct a bibliometric analysis: An overview and guidelines," Journal of business research,133, pp. 285-296, 2021.

J. P. Romanelli, M. C. P. Gonçalves, L. F. de Abreu Pestana, J. A. H. Soares, R. S. Boschi and D. F. Andrade, "Four challenges when conducting bibliometric reviews and how to deal with them," Environmental Science and Pollution Research, pp. 1-11, 2021.

A. Khan, J. W. Goodell, M. K. Hassan and A. Paltrinieri, "A bibliometric review of finance bibliometric papers Ashraf Khan, John W Goodell, M Kabir Hassan, Andrea Paltrinieri," Finance Research Letters, 47, p. 102520, 2022.

A. Rifai, R. F. Dalimunthe, P. Lumbanraja and Y. Absah, Literature Review: Analysis of Creative Performance of Employees in Government in Indonesia., 625-631.: Achieving Sustainable Business Through AI, Technology Education and Computer Science,, 2024.

H. Arruda, E. R. Silva, M. Lessa, D. Proença Jr and R. Bartholo, "JMLA, 110(3)," VOSviewer and bibliometrix. Journal of the Medical Library Association, p. 392, 2022.

Y. Sinambela and A. Rifai, "American Journal of Open Research, 3(4)," Bibliometric Analysis of Road Damage Due to High Rainfall Intensity in Mountainous Areas Using VOSviewer. OPSearch:, pp. 940-952., 2024.

B. Hammouti, I. Aichouch, Y. Kachbou, K. Azzaoui and R. Touzani, "Bibliometric analysis of global research trends on UMI using Scopus database and VOSviewer from 1987 - 2024," J. Mater. Environ. Sci, 16(4), pp. 548-561, 2025.

V. A. Ricardo, A. I. Rifai, A. S. Savitri and J. Prasetijo, A Bibliometric Analysis of Drinking Water Distribution In Coastal Areas Using Vosviewer., 2(9), 1980-1988.: Asian Journal of Social and Humanities,, 2024.

Rahayu, S. Nindi, Liddini, Hasanah and Maarif.S, "Mosharafa: Jurnal Pendidikan Matematika, 11(2)," Berpikir Kreatif Matematis: Sebuah Pemetaan Literatur dengan Analisis Bibliometri Menggunakan Vos Viewer, pp. 179-190., 2022.

V. Vendhy, A. Rifai and A. Savitri, "Jurnal Syntax Transformation, 5(5),," A Bibliometric Analysis of Drinking Water Management on an Island using Vosviewer., pp. 792-800, 2024.

D. Guleria and G. Kaur, "Bibliometric analysis of ecopreneurship using VOSviewer and RStudio Bibliometrix, 1989 - 2019," Library Hi Tech, 39(4), pp. 1001-1024, 2021.

V. D. Ekaputra, V. Gaffar and M. Arief, "Pemasaran bandara: sistematik literatur review kajian bibliometrik berdasarkan database google scholar dan crossref tahun 2019 - 2022," JJPI (Jurnal Penelitian Pendidikan Indonesia), 10(2), pp. 647-657, 2024.

A. M. Lubis, A. I. Rifai and A. Savitri, Bibliometric Analysis of Drainage System Performance Against Urban Flooding Using Vosviewer., 3(5), 990-996.: OPSearch: American Journal of Open Research,, 2024.

D. Gultom, A. Rifai, M. Pamadi and M. Isradi, "Journal of Social Science (JoSS), 3(6)," Bibliometric Analysis Of High-Rise Building Planning With Cpm And Pert Methods Using Vosviewer, pp. 1437-1446, 2024.

P. Sinaga, A. Rifai and M. Pamadi, "OPSearch: American Journal of Open Research, 3(5)," Bibliometric analysis of productivity instruments in construction management project management using Vosviewer, pp. 980-989, 2024.

A. Rifai, D. Endriansah, J. Prasetijo and M. Isradi, "In Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Railway and Transportation 2023 (ICORT 2023) (Vol. 231, p. 386). Springer Nature.," The Corrosion Effect of Gusset Plates on the Steel Joint Structure of Bridges: A literature review based on VOS viewer, pp. 1-13, 2024.